If it is a fact of history that Jesus is risen from the dead, then Easter is not just a fun story for children—it’s the most important event in human history. And if Jesus isn’t risen, then by the Bible’s own admission, those who follow Jesus “are of all men the most to be pitied” (1 Corinthians 15:19).
The question is…
There are five historical facts surrounding Jesus of Nazareth. These facts are agreed upon by an overwhelming majority of historical scholars, whether they believe in God or not. Not only do you have to decide what best explains each fact. You have to decide what can best explain them all.
History remembers Jesus of Nazareth as an itinerant Jewish preacher and the adopted son of a Galilean carpenter. Following a brief but lively public ministry, Jesus was tried by Jewish and Gentile courts on a charge of blasphemy for His claim to be uniquely “One” with God. For this, Jesus was rejected by the leaders of Israel, and then scourged and crucified to death by a band of professional Roman soldiers.
The life and death of Jesus are witnessed by the 27 books of the New Testament.
In fact, Jesus’ life and death are established by independent Roman and Jewish sources as well (Josephus, Tacitus, and The Talmud—among others).
Prior to His death, Jesus’ disciples anticipated that as the long-awaited Jewish Messiah, Jesus would deliver Israel from political subjugation to Rome. The furthest thing from their minds was the possibility that their Messiah would be arrested and put to death. When He was, Jesus’ followers abandoned Him and hid themselves away lest they join Him in being tortured and killed.
Soon after, all but Judas Iscariot (who had betrayed Jesus and died at his own hands), began boldly teaching that they had seen Jesus risen—and that eternal life with God is promised to those who place their love and trust in Jesus Christ for life and the forgiveness of sin.
The disciples had nothing material to gain from their teachings. Indeed, they suffered poverty, torture, and death for following Jesus. Yet not one of them changed their story. A profound experience changed each of these men—but what was it?
The disciples were convinced that they had in fact met the risen Christ.
Saul of Tarsus was a student of the eminent first-century Jewish Rabbi Gamaliel. Saul was a Pharisee who saw Christianity as a vile heresy to be quickly and decisively stamped out. He oversaw the execution of Christians, and travelled far and wide to pull Christians out of their homes to face torture and death. Saul was a soldier of inquisition (Acts 8:1-3).
It was on such a journey that Saul met the risen Jesus (Acts 9). In the aftermath of that meeting, Saul of Tarsus became better known as the Apostle Paul.
Paul is the most influential Christian missionary of all time. Indeed, it was the sworn enemy of Jesus Christ who eventually wrote down two-thirds of the New Testament, and greatly influenced the rest of it. Something profound caused Paul to change his mind. Ironically, Paul was eventually tortured and killed for following Jesus. Why?
Because Paul was convinced that he had in fact met the risen Christ.
The Bible records that Jesus’ brothers didn’t believe in Him while He was alive
(John 7:5). Even so, His brother James became the Pastor of the church in Jerusalem soon after Jesus’ death. Why would James faithfully serve a dead Jesus when he wouldn’t follow a living One?
Because something profound caused James to change his mind. The earliest Christian tradition records that the risen Jesus especially appeared to His brother James (1 Corinthians 15:3-9). In the end, James was tortured and killed for believing in Jesus. Why?
Because James was convinced that he had in fact met the risen Christ.
In the aftermath of Jesus’ crucifixion, belief in Jesus began spreading rapidly. Jesus had been killed for the express purpose of preventing this outcome. Both Jewish and Roman governments had every reason to intervene so as to limit the growing influence of Jesus Christ. Indeed, Jesus was proving to be a bigger problem dead than He ever was alive.
Now, consider this carefully. Nothing would have smothered Christianity in the cradle more effectively than tying Jesus’ rotting corpse to a donkey-cart and parading it through Jerusalem for all to see. But that never happened. Why not?
The tomb that Jesus was buried in was the property of a well-known Jewish statesman familiar to both Jewish and Roman governments. They didn’t forget where they put Jesus. In fact, on the third day He wasn’t there anymore—but His clothes were.
Did the disciples really come out of fearful hiding to steal Jesus’ body, and then lie about it for the rest of their lives for no personal benefit? Did they really endure torture and death in order to preserve their lie? Was their made-up story so persuasive that it convinced a hardened skeptic like James. Was their novel theology so compelling that it converted an educated enemy like Saul? And if Easter is a lie, why didn’t even one of these men break when facing torture and death?
The best explanation is that Jesus Is Risen.
If Jesus is in fact risen, then Jesus Is in fact exactly Who He claimed to be.
"HE IS" God; "HE IS" with God; and "HE IS" the Lamb of God given to save the world.
Jesus Is Love come down to die, so that in Him you can be raised up to live. Because Jesus is risen, you can trust that what He says is the Truth (John 14:6).
His question for you is:
Michael Licona, Philosopher & Historian
Be notified when new content is posted.
Preliminary Questions
- Because Ideas Matter -
Copyright © 2024 Preliminary Questions - All Rights Reserved.